5 Films You (Maybe) Didn’t Know Were Based on Graphic Novels

American Splendor #1Hollywood seems to have picked up a new habit; that of adapting comic books into films. There’s Batman, Iron Man, Spiderman, Superman, the X-Men… OK, so I jest about the unfortunate name legacy left to some of these franchises, but a lot of them have translated successfully into high grossing films.

Now you may be seeing a trend in these movies, there’s a large showing for Marvel and DC’s finest, but there’s still a lot of love out there for the more obscure, more adult comics. I’ve already mentioned the WE3 movie on these digital pages and works like From Hell, Sin City, V for Vendetta and 30 Days of Night have shown that the graphic novel format can translate just as well.

I have to admit I’m not a fan of superheroes in comic books, the trappings of the underwear pervert have formed a gestalt of ideas it seems hard to break out of (with the exception of Animal Man.) Don’t get me wrong, I like the films that have grown from these established characters, but I’m more of a Transmetropolitan kind of guy. With this in mind I went to see The Spirit last week and was thoroughly disappointed; with Frank Miller, a man with an amazing eye for using shadow contrasts, and the source material from Will Eisner, the father of comics I expected a triumph, instead I left the theatre bored and bemused.

To this end I’ve decided to list, for your delectation, 5 movies that you may not know were based on comic books…

A History of Violence

Based on the graphic novel of the same name, A History of Violence tells the story of a cafe owner trying to escape the repercussions of a horrendous crime he committed as a youth. The comic was written by John Wagner, one of the creators of British comics icon Judge Dredd (which also became a film, but a truly abysmal one) and drawn by Vince Locke, famous for his work on the Brief Lives run of Sandman. the film holds an 87% fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes and was nominated for two Oscars, one of them for Josh Olsen’s adaptation of the original comic’s script. The film differs quite a lot from the graphic novel, but the central themes and tone are retained effectively.

Road to Perdition

The original Road to Perdition was written by Max Allan Collins, an insanely talented writer of novels and script, as well as directing and writing for a band. The bast. The art for the books was drawn by Richard Piers Rayner, an old DC/Marvel hand and now Middlesborough FC’s resident artist. The books themselves tell the story of a disgraced mafia enforcer trying to raise his son in a world of violence, a theme which is retained in the film version. Sadly David Self‘s treatment of the adaptation was tinkered about with by a rotating group of writers at the behest of Spielberg and resulted in the dilution of the film’s message.

The Crow

Perennial goth posterboy Eric started life as the main character of J. O’Barr‘s The Crow. As the writer and artist James created The Crow as a way of dealing with the death of his fiancée at the hands of a drunk driver, a fact mirrored in the fiction as Eric’s fiancée is killed in the book. In this case I feel the film outshines the comic. O’Barr’s personal misery is evident in the book, but comes across as a little too goth for my tastes. The film was directed by Alex Proyas, director of the fantastic Dark City, and the production of the film famously led to the death of it’s star Brandon Lee.

American Splendor

Yeah, if you’ve seen this then you know it’s a biopic of autobiographic comic creator Harvey Pekar. the film takes aspects of Pekar’s life and mixes them with the elements of his American Splendor series to tell the story of Pekar’s life and the creation of the series he’s famous for. Drawn by different artists, including legendary underground comics genius R. Crumb the comic series is to my mind one of the best examples of exactly what can be done with the graphic novel medium. The film currently enjoys a 94% fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes. See it, its bloody good.

Ghost World

Not strictly its own comic book, Ghost World was a story arc from creator Daniel Clowes‘ alt comic Eightball. It tells the tale of two 90’s high school graduates and the decline of their friendship as they transition into adulthood. Directed by Terry Zwigoff the man responsible for Crumb, a documentary about the life of R. Crumb (which I’ve not managed to see yet) the movie garnered Clowes an Oscar nomination for his treatment of his own work.

5 thoughts on “5 Films You (Maybe) Didn’t Know Were Based on Graphic Novels

  1. Ado

    Agreed on “The Spirit” front, it was very underwhelming. Some good actors in it and it looked very nice, it just seemed like Sin City Lite, for those of you who like all the flavour with none of the substance. Competently produced and inoffensive, but worse for it.

    As for other poor comic/graphics movies, did anyone see “Punisher”?? How much did that one suck?? I’ll tell you, a hell of a lot. There even making a sequel and it looks about as good as the first, just with more guns…

    As for goodies, “Sin City” shouldn’t have worked but did and brilliantly. Also, big props to Chris Nolan for pulling Batman back from the fire and reinvigorating that franchise to the point where it might even win some awards (not that that matters, but it’s a mark of how much distance he and his team have put between “Dark Knight” and “Batman and Robin”)

    As for the outlook, “Y: The Last Man” (a personal favourite of mine) is in pre-production. Looking at a three film run (as seems standard fare these days) but Shia LeBouf is rumoured to be in line to play Yorik Brown, having worked with the director on “Disturbia” and “Eagle Eye”. I do not have the words to express how much this pains me, I would literally give a kidney not to see this wet fart-with-follow-through of an actor play one of my most beloved fictional characters… He’s already ruined Indiana Jones and Transformers (with help from Lucas and Bay, but he’s the common thread). I’m praying for a real actor or at least an unknown to do this stand-out book justice.

    I’m also looking forward to the inevitable Avengers movie. The latest batch of Marvel movies (well, “Iron Man” and “Incredible Hulk”) have both proved a fine mix of comic and reality, with excellent talent in the lead roles too. ot to forget Sam Jackson in the role of Nick Fury (as seen in the final reels of these two movies) I have high hopes for the Ultimates story line to making an appearance, although (bring it full circle) Sammy J did star in “The Spirit” too.


  2. Gazz

    Ghost World is a personal favourite of mine, and although I’ve never owned the comic I do have a cbr of it. I absolutely adore the film, if only more comic-movie translations were handled with this reverance.

    I’m in agreement with Ado on the Y issue. Hopefully Share the Beef will meet with an untimely accident…[cue comic cliched diabolical laughther]. Also Ultimate Nick Fury FTW 😀

    A few more to add to the list if i may:

    Men in Black is loosely based on a comic by Lowell Cunningham and Sandy Carruthers. Pretty sure everyone knows about this film…

    The League of Extraordianry Gentleman was created by Alan Moore and was a much darker experience than the dribble released by 20th Century Fox. The original story features characters from fiction, such as the Invisible man, now a rapist, and Allan Quatermain, now an opium addict, thrown together by fate into a ragtag bunch of ‘Crime’ fighters. Don’t be put off by the film, the books are far from the Hollywood picture.

    Wanted Mark Millar’s story ruined… see also Kick Ass


  3. Neil

    Oh god the League film sucked so hard. Why put Dorian Grey and Tom Sawyer in it? Why so happy clappy? And why the hell does Captain Nemo know kung-fu?

    Y should be a good laugh, monkeys are always funny.


  4. Ado

    I have learnt my lesson well. If The Shy Beef is in Y, I will not be watching it at all. I’d infact be tempted to go to the US and hit him in the face until he agrees not to play the role. Then I’d kick him in the gut for ruining Indiana Jones, the floppy haired retard…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s